Call For A Free Consultation - Available 24/7

Founding Member of Moshes Law, P.C.
During his years of practice, Yuriy has concentrated in litigation and real estate transactions as his areas of expertise.

What Is a Purchase and Sale Agreement in NYC? What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know

In my years handling New York real estate transactions, the purchase and sale agreement is the document I see most commonly misunderstood — and most dangerously overlooked. Buyers often sign it assuming it’s routine paperwork. Sellers sometimes treat it as a formality. It is neither.

A purchase and sale agreement (commonly called a P&S agreement or PSA) is a legally binding contract that sets the terms and conditions governing a real estate transaction. Get it right and your deal moves smoothly toward closing. Get it wrong and you could lose your deposit, face legal liability, or find yourself locked into a deal you can’t get out of.

This guide covers what a PSA actually does, what it must include under New York law, and why the attorney you hire to draft or review it matters more than most buyers realize.

Yuriy Moshes

AUTHOR YURIY MOSHES, ESQ

Founding Member of Moshes Law, P.C.

During his years of practice, Yuriy has concentrated in litigation
and real estate transactions as his areas of expertise

Do You Need a Real Estate Attorney?

If you need legal help with a real estate transaction, set up a FREE consultation today.

What Is a Purchase and Sale Agreement — and How Is It Different from a Purchase Agreement?

This distinction trips up a lot of buyers. Here’s the straightforward version.

A purchase agreement is the final contract that formally transfers property from seller to buyer. It’s signed at closing. A purchase and sale agreement comes earlier — it’s the contract that governs the entire process leading up to that closing. It outlines what each party must do, what conditions must be met, and what happens if something goes wrong before you get to the closing table.

Think of the PSA as the rules of the transaction. The purchase agreement is how the transaction ends.

Both are legally binding. Both carry real consequences if breached. And in New York, both should be reviewed by an attorney before you sign.

Who Drafts the Purchase and Sale Agreement in New York?

This surprises many first-time buyers: in New York, a  real estate attorney drafts the purchase and sale agreement — not the real estate agent.

That’s different from most other states, where agents often handle contract preparation. In New York, attorney involvement is standard practice and, frankly, essential given the complexity of the local market. If anyone other than a licensed attorney is drafting your PSA, that’s a problem worth addressing immediately.

Key Elements Every P&S Agreement Should Include

New York real estate deals vary, but a solid purchase and sale agreement will always address the following:

1. Purchase Price: The agreed-upon sale price, including any seller concessions or credits negotiated between the parties. This number can shift during negotiations, and the PSA should reflect whatever was actually agreed.

2. Earnest Money Deposit: How much the buyer is putting down as a deposit, when it’s due, and the exact conditions under which it’s refundable — or not. In New York, deposits are typically held in escrow by the seller’s attorney. Buyers need to understand that under certain circumstances, walking away can mean losing that money entirely.

3. Closing Date: The target date for finalizing the transaction. In NYC real estate, closing dates move. Co-op board reviews, mortgage underwriting delays, and title issues all cause timelines to shift. A well-drafted PSA addresses how delays are handled so neither party is left exposed.

4. Contingencies: Contingencies are conditions that must be satisfied for the transaction to move forward. Common ones in New York include:

If a contingency isn’t met, either the buyer or seller may have the right to cancel. The language here is critical. Vague contingency terms are one of the leading causes of real estate disputes I see in my practice.

5. Title Condition and Title Insurance: The PSA should require the seller to deliver marketable title — meaning no liens, encumbrances, or legal defects. It should also specify which title insurance company is involved and who selects it. In New York, the buyer typically chooses the title company.

How Funds Are Transferred

Whether the deal is cash or financed, the PSA needs to spell out exactly how money moves at closing — wire transfer, escrow, certified funds. Ambiguity here creates problems when it matters most.

Additional Costs and Allocations

New York  real estate transactions come with significant costs beyond the sale price: transfer taxes, title insurance premiums, attorney fees, mortgage recording taxes, and more. The PSA should clearly state who pays what so there are no surprises at the closing table.

What Happens After the Purchase and Sale Agreement Is Signed?

Signing the PSA is the starting gun, not the finish line. Here’s what typically follows in a New York real estate transaction:

1. Title Search: The buyer’s attorney orders a thorough title search to confirm the seller has the legal right to sell and that the property is free of outstanding liens or defects. In New York City — where properties change hands frequently and carry complex histories — this step is not optional.

2. Home Inspection: A licensed inspector examines the property for structural issues, code violations, and necessary repairs. Findings can trigger renegotiations or allow the buyer to invoke an inspection contingency and exit the deal.

3. Mortgage Commitment: Pre-approval is not a mortgage commitment. After the PSA is signed, the buyer’s lender formally underwrites the loan and issues a written commitment. This takes time, and the PSA should give the buyer adequate time to secure it.

4. Co-op or Condo Board Approval: This step is unique to New York — and it’s the one that catches the most out-of-state buyers off guard. Co-op purchases require a board package, an interview, and formal board approval. This process can add weeks or months to a transaction and can result in rejection. A good PSA accounts for this possibility.

5. Closing: Both parties meet with their attorneys, final documents are signed, funds are transferred, and title is recorded. In New York, having your attorney present at closing isn’t optional — it’s standard, and it protects you when last-minute issues arise.

Why the Attorney You Choose Matters

New York real estate law is not generic. The state has its own transfer tax rules, co-op regulations, attorney customs, and disclosure obligations. A PSA that works in another state may be wholly inadequate for a New York transaction.

I’ve seen buyers lose deposits over imprecise contingency language. I’ve seen sellers get stuck in deals they couldn’t exit because the contract didn’t account for obvious risks. These are not rare situations — they’re what happens when people treat the purchase and sale agreement as a formality rather than the foundational legal document it actually is.

An experienced real estate attorney will draft a PSA that reflects the realities of your specific deal, protects you where you’re most vulnerable, and gives you a clear path to closing.

Conclusion

A purchase and sale agreement is not boilerplate. In New York, it is the document that controls everything — your deposit, your timeline, your right to exit, and your path to owning the property. Every clause matters. Every contingency has consequences. And every day you wait to get legal guidance is a day you’re exposed.

Buying or selling real estate in New York City is one of the largest financial decisions most people make in their lifetime. The PSA is where that decision is first put into writing and made legally enforceable. Treating it as a checkbox — something to sign quickly and move past — is one of the most costly mistakes I see clients make, sometimes before they even realize anything has gone wrong.

Get an attorney involved early. Have the agreement reviewed before you sign, not after. And if something in the contract doesn’t make sense to you, ask — because in real estate, the things that get glossed over are almost always the things that come back to cause problems later.

Moshes law group photo

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a PSA in real estate?

PSA stands for Purchase and Sale Agreement. It's the binding pre-closing contract that governs the process and conditions of a real estate transaction. It's different from the final purchase agreement signed at closing.

Can a real estate attorney draft a real estate contract in New York?

Yes — and in New York, this is the norm. Real estate agents are not permitted to draft contracts. That responsibility belongs to licensed attorneys, which is one reason attorney involvement in New York transactions is standard on both sides.

Who prepares the purchase agreement in New York?

The seller's attorney typically prepares the initial contract. The buyer's attorney reviews it, negotiates changes, and advises the buyer before it's signed. This back-and-forth between attorneys is a standard part of the New York real estate process.

Is a purchase and sale agreement legally binding?

Yes. Once both parties sign, they are bound by its terms. Backing out without legal justification — such as a failed contingency — can result in losing your deposit or facing legal action.

What does a purchase contract attorney do?

A purchase contract attorney drafts, reviews, and negotiates the PSA on your behalf. They identify problematic language, protect your interests on contingencies and deposits, coordinate with the title company and opposing counsel, and represent you at closing.

RELATED POSTS

    Free Case Evaluation





    View our Terms & Conditions &
    Privacy Policy
    .

    As Seen On

    Logo Avvo
    Logo Nolo
    Logo Law360
    Logo Super Lawyers
    Logo Realtor.com
    Logo BLF
    Logo Business
    Logo 1010 Wins
    Logo New York Post